At Torgenson Law, when we begin representing a new personal injury client, our first mission is to determine who will be liable for damages. Obviously, our first instinct is to identify the individual who actually caused the injury, as he or she is directly liable for our client’s injury. However, our investigation does not end there. Depending on the circumstances of the injury, the negligent individual’s employer may be vicariously liable for its employee’s negligence as well. In Arizona, this doctrine of liability is known as respondeat superior, which means “let the master answer.” In short, the company, corporation, or business that employs the individual will be vicariously liable for the individual’s wrongful acts when those acts occur within the course and scope of employment.
On its face, this liability doctrine seems relatively straightforward: If an employee negligently causes personal injuries while he or she is at work, the employer is liable. However, it is not as simple as that. Here are some questions one must ask to effectively assert a vicarious liability claim against an employer.
Did an Employment Relationship Exist?
The key factor in determining whether an employment relationship existed is whether the employer has the right to control or direct the individual’s actions. Now, this does not require that there be an employment contract, nor must the employer compensate the employee for his services. Therefore, even interns and volunteers can be “employees” for the purposes of vicarious liability. With that said, it is important to show that the employee was under the control or direction of the employer when the injury occurred.
Did the Wrongful Act Occur Within the Course and Scope of Employment?
In Arizona, there are three factors considered to determine if an employee’s act occurred within the scope of his employment: (1) Whether the conduct was the type he was employed to perform; (2) whether the conduct occurred within the time and space limits authorized by the employer; and (3) whether the conduct was done in furtherance of the employer’s business.
Each of these factors can be established if there is evidence that the employer specifically required or instructed the employee to perform certain job responsibilities. One of the most common examples involving the issue of “course and scope” would be an employee who is driving company car, truck, or tractor-trailer. For example, if an employee for a furniture store is instructed to deliver a furniture in the company tractor-trailer to an address, runs a red light, and causes an injury, his employer, the furniture store, will be vicariously liable for those damages. On the other hand, if the same person decides to pick up groceries on his way back to the furniture store after delivering the furniture, these personal activities typically will not fall within the scope of employment.
Additionally, employers will be vicariously liable for acts that are incidental to that employment. To illustrate, if a bouncer at a bar negligently or intentionally causes harm to a patron while kicking them out of the bar, the bar itself will be vicariously liable. While if the bouncer committed similar wrongful acts on his day off at a different bar, his employer would likely not be vicariously liable.
To convince a jury that it is not liable, an employer may argue that it specifically forbade the activity that caused the injury. Perhaps, the pizza restaurant had a strict policy against running red lights, or the bar prohibited intentionally injuring patrons that were kicked out of the bar. However, Arizona law is clear that even an employee’s wrongful acts are in direct conflict with an employer’s policies, this does not take the employee outside the scope of employment. The employer can still be held vicariously liable.
As Arizona Injury Lawyers, we know that it is your legal right to be compensated when you are injured due to the negligence of another. Under certain circumstances, an employer as opposed to or in addition to a negligent employee may be responsible for your personal injury compensations. These types of cases require the skills of an experienced legal team like Torgenson Law. If you or a loved one is injured, do not hesitate to call (602) 759-0012. We will not leave a stone unturned when it comes to your personal injury needs.
Looking for Torgenson Law updates on your social media feed? Give us a follow on: